Sri Lankan attacks Shashi

It had to begin. Most of the analysis of Shashi’s candidacy has started with the assumption that it entered into a void created by weak candidates. But now,a former Sri Lankan Assistant Foreign Secretary attacks Shashi’s candidacy in the press. We believe that this is the first time that a public figure of a country that is supporting one candidate is publicly attacking the candidacy of another.

We also note timing. Shashi is going to Gambia next week for the AU meeting. And Dhanapala was in Canada to meet with government officials there.

The article asks a series of interesting questions about the problems of an Indian candidacy, for example:

Further the Hindu – Muslims riots which have become an everyday feature in India in recent times will also not lend to Islamic countries supporting the Indian nominee. Then there is the unresolved Kashmir issue; a UN Observer Mission is stationed in Kashmir; what would Tharoor’s position be if a fifth war broke out between Pakistan and India over Kashmir?

But then the real viciousness begins. First that Sri Lanka’s pride was challenged by India’s non-endorsement:

When India did not declare its support for our candidate it was perceived here as another unfriendly act; I was under the impression that we not only shared history but also have common norms, shared values and interests and considering her frequent statements regarding the close relations that exist between our two countries, (”our two countries are inseparable, your territorial integrity and ours are one” etc) to have enthusiastically supported our eminent candidate as if he was their own candidate but now we realize that India had her own agenda and the close friendship they profess to is confined to mere words.

Then he goes on to suggest that Shashi should drop out and India should back Dhanapala:

If India wishes us and the world to accept her as an emerging super power and as the regional power then she should act like one

I do hope that India would test the waters and then gracefully withdraw her candidate if there is even the smallest possibility that he would not make it. She should save herself the embarrassment of rejection by the international community.India should then support Dhanapala as a consensus South Asian candidate or is this too much to expect?

Our sense is still that Dhanapala is a failed candidate, for reasons which we have described here. But interesting nonetheless. This campaign is really entering a new stage.

No Responses to “Sri Lankan attacks Shashi”

  1. Vijay Kumar R. Says:

    Shashi Tharoor’s candidacy is a disaster for India and the Indian people. First of all, Tharoor has no chance of being elected Secretary-General. The US is looking for a UN outsider, who will be critical of the Secretariat and take tough charge of the needed house-cleaning. Tharoor has always defended the Secretariat, even its performance over Bosnia and Rwanda and has never called for the sort of root and branch change in UN management that is necessary. Shashi Tharoor is also seen within the Secretariat as a has-been, ousted from Kofi Annan’s inner circle years ago, and busy with self-publicity. He will be hard pressed to identify what he has done to reform his sprawling department. Secondly, if India was to nominate a candiate and risk a Chinese veto, it could have nominated any one of dozens of very experienced and impressive Indian diplomats. But by nominated a joke candidate, India will have both sent a signal that its no longer interested in a permanent Security Council Seat, and given up whatever chance there might have been to have a credible Indian on the 38th floor.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: