National Identity in UNSG Race

We are still awash in news of Shashi's announcement. But something has struck us. referred to it as the "long anticipated announcement". Who anticipated this and why? And, indeed, how?

First, UN insiders seem to have believed that Shashi was going to run. It was apparent that he had been campaigning. But when was he going to announce?

Second, why? He is probably the most articulate of the UN insiders. If Kofi Annan is to be the model of a UNSG — a career UN diplomat — then Shashi is, without question, the most superior specimen of that model. Indeed, the argument for Shashi's candidacy will be that he is the most qualified individual for the position. This differed somewhat from the arguments for Ban Ki-moon and Sathirathai, both of whom seemed to be arguing that they, as perhaps the most talented representatives of their countries, were somehow qualified for the position. Is Ban Ki-moon in any way extraordinary? Perhaps, but not in the same way that Shashi is.

But the UN is the United Nations. So one question was which Nation would step forth and recommend him for the position? And to what extent will Shashi be viewed in his own right or as an Indian?

Shashi will be arguing that he is just a person who happens to be Indian. And the Indians appear to be arguing for an Indian candidate. And, so far, the newspapers are with the Indian interpretation. Just look at some titles: "India Sets Aim at the UN's Top Job," "India Makes a Move," or "Pak Challenges India for Top Job."

This has been a fundamental part of the coverage of the race in Bangkok or Seoul also. The Bangkok Post is reporting that "India" is running against them. And it is clear when "India" is using the full power of its diplomatic service to push Shashi.  Because Shashi is the right man? He may well be. But when the Spokesman for the Ministry of External Affairs says:

It's a matter of pride if a son of India and son of Asia becomes United Nations Secretary-General.

And they are willing to spend millions of dollars to make it happen. It will certainly help Shashi to have those resources. But ultimately, it may hurt him to be the Indian champion in this race. It will make it harder for the job for his own skills rather than because India's time has come — like South Korea, Thailand, or, indeed, Asia.

2 Responses to “National Identity in UNSG Race”

  1. Chapter15 » Blog Archive » Ban for UNSG: Thanking the World for Korea’s success Says:

    […] Ban Ki-moon tells us directly that his candidacy is not about himself. We recently pointed out that the issue of national identity is taking an increasingly central role in this race. From the national pride of India to these kinds of statements from Ban. […]

  2. Dr.Yashanvitha Says:

    India as a Nation behaves as one loving Family.But at the same, Indians are not arguing on the basis of his National identity.It is just the misperceptions of medias.Dr. Tharoor himself has declared that he is just a person who happens to be Indian, but he will not be India’s UNSG.But his citizenship should not rule out his extra ordinary eligibility as a person in his own right.Continental & National identity is arising because of the selection based on the regional rotation.Dr. Tharoor himself has declared that his indepedence of views on regional rotation remains the same even after the nomination.UN is an organisation by itself & not yet a democratic, secular,one world government where people as Nations send their representative to elect the national politicians & advisors to politicians,who are finding their eligibility.One need to be diplomatic & not involved in his National politics to compete for the post of UNSG.As long as there are divisions between developed & developing Nations in its by laws,it cannot be assumed as a secular world government by the general public of the whole world.As a organisation, with the interests of Global welfare, not with the interests of any one particular Nation’s welfare,if it has to function effectively, then Dr. Shashi Tharoor’s universal, impartial, secular mind is a blessing to UN & the world.Because, his unbiased thoughts & articles,along with his diplomacy are real treasures to the world & the organisation like U.N. in initiating its objectives of global welfare & peace.His words assert that he is not just a person of styles, but a person with deeper substance.Words have the power, because it do echoes in the minds & the whole world.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: